Thousands of fishermen flock here to catch the freshwater fish each summer, but this little town is also famous for a very different haul - hooking US presidents.
The voters here have an uncanny knack of naming the nation's next president. They're currently on a winning streak stretching back over 70 years to the election of Harry S Truman in 1944.
So that's 18 elections when this county has correctly chosen the presidential candidate to win Ohio. And as generations of hopeful politicians have found, if you don't win the swing state of Ohio you'll never get to the White House.
The people of Port Clinton say there's no great secret to being ballot barometers. They're just regular Americans, reflecting the average national household income of about $52,000 (£36,000).
So it seemed the ideal place for Sky News to get an indication of the next president nine months before election day.
In a town named Port Clinton you'd have thought they'd be hot for Hillary. But round at the Perfect Color hair salon, Ray Dinallo clearly wasn't keen on Mrs Clinton.
"No, I'd never vote for Hillary," Ray told me. "After the Benghazi affair and the email scandal, I don't think I could ever trust her."
Ray, an airline pilot, seemed to echo the views of many voters here when he told me he wasn't a typical Republican or Democrat. He just settles on the best candidate, whatever the party.
Next door at the Great Lakes Popcorn Co, Loria Hofer said she'd love to vote for Bill Clinton again. But she wasn't so sure about Hillary.
"I'm a Democrat and my husband's voting for Hillary. But I'm leaning towards Donald Trump."
As she stirred a pan of her legendary Wild Walleye cajun spiced popcorn, Loria told me: "I think Trump will stir the pot. I like it that he says it how it is."
But at Coffee Express, baristas Jamie and Curtis laughed out loud when I mentioned The Donald. "You heard him speak?" asked Curtis Kouts. "He's just crazy. We're both going for Hillary."
At a nearby table, Craig Olszewski, a coastguard known as Cookie, was less dismissive of Trump. But he was choosing between Republicans Ted Cruz and Marco Rubio.
As a Democrat, young teacher Lisa Heineman said she was backing Bernie. "I like Hillary. But it's Bernie Sanders for me because he's more radical and he'll take a risk on something new."
One thing that's as clear as the winter sky over Lake Erie - most people are fed up with central government and politics as usual. They're looking for an outsider, someone who will take on the establishment.
In Jim's Taxidermy shop, surrounded by the unseeing eyes of coyotes and bison, mountain lions and walleye, taxidermist Todd Wendt put me straight. He thinks Washington politicians are about as slippery as the fish he preserves.
"You see, we mount these critters, we don't stuff 'em, " Todd told me with graphic relish. "So I don't feel stuffed by the government. I feel mounted."
Todd wants someone in the White House, who'll give power back to the people. His choice - Senator Ted Cruz.
Port Clinton's new mayor, Hugh Wheeler, is a heavy vehicle mechanic by profession. And he clearly thinks whoever they back as the next president needs to do a repair job on the nation.
"Above all we need to renew the American Dream and make America great again," said Mayor Wheeler. "And I'm sure our new leader will get that message loud and clear."
With so many presidential candidates to choose from, it's hardly surprising that even the folk of Ohio are a little confused at this early stage of the campaign. But come November it's a fair bet that the walleye fishermen of Port Clinton will land another winner.